保持不义之举-IP禁令被认为有害吗？用什么代替呢？

问题描述

我主持了一个讨论论坛的技术方面，该论坛受到了一个巨魔（据我所知，是一个自然人）的困扰。社区似乎已经用尽了所有通信手段（毫无疑问，这是 net.troll

我可能需要阻止该人访问该网站，但我不确定如何（它已经拒绝自行离开）。该站点需要使用电子邮件地址注册，该电子邮件地址将为您提供用户名。我可以阻止用户名，但是巨魔可以轻松地注册一个新用户名。

现在，关于如何执行IP禁令的问题解答很多。

知识产权禁令对阻止巨魔有用吗？如果没有，那该怎么办？或者，我可以将IP禁令与其他保护形式结合起来吗？

我与IP禁令有关的问题很多：

• 巨魔来自几个不同的IP块（家庭/学校/开放式wifi /...？）


• IP地址似乎是动态分​​配的（通常在此处与DSL一起使用）


• 我怀疑可能通过代理和/或VPN用新帐户对袜子进行了


• 至少在一种情况下，其他用户来自同一IP（我怀疑是大型NAT-已确认：在这种情况下，整个大学都从单个公共IP地址后面访问网络）
b $ b

似乎我将通过技术手段来解决一个社会问题，而且前景似乎黯淡。

解决方案

您可以实现全局忽略吗？最好的情况是，这使巨魔可以看到自己的帖子，但没人能看到它们。这使巨魔没有得到愤怒的社区成员的反馈，但是没有任何线索表明看不到帖子的原因。我看过这项工作，这意味着不良行为已停止。

I run the technical side of a discussion forum, which is plagued by a troll (a single physical person, as far as I can tell). It seems that the community has exhausted all means of communication (it is, beyond reasonable doubt, a net.troll, not a clueless user), including face-to-face.

I may need to block that person from visiting the site, but I'm not sure how (it already refused to leave of its own accord). The site needs registration with an e-mail address, which gets you a username. I could block the username, but the troll could just as easily register a new one.

Now, there are plenty of Q&A on "how to do an IP ban and at what layer", but is it worth the hassle?

Would an IP ban be useful for blocking a troll? If not, what? Or, could I combine an IP ban with some other form of protection?

The issues I have with IP bans are numerous:

• the troll comes in from several different IP blocks (home/school/open wifi/...?)
• the IP addresses seem to be dynamically assigned (usual with DSL here)
• I suspect sock-puppetting with new accounts, possibly through proxies and/or VPN
• at least in one case, there are other users coming in from the same IP (I suspect a large NAT - confirmed: in this case, there's a whole university accessing the web from behind a single public IP addresss)

It seems that I'll be fighting a social issue through technological means, and the prospects of that seem bleak.

解决方案

Can you implement a "global ignore"? At its finest, this lets the troll see its own posts, but nobody else sees them at all. This gives the troll no feedback from outraged community members, but no clue that the reason is the posts can't be seen. I have seen this work, meaning that the bad behaviour stopped.

这篇关于保持不义之举-IP禁令被认为有害吗？用什么代替呢？的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持！