以下是Scala的TraversableOnce特性的reduceLeft方法的来源。读取var acc: B = 0.asInstanceOf[B]的行发生了什么?

在我看来,如果我在字符串列表上调用它,例如List("a", "b", "c"),这将导致出现0.asInstanceOf[String]。但是,如果我直接尝试0.asInstanceOf[String],则会在运行时抛出ClassCastException

该行发生了什么,为什么与在字符串列表中调用时直接调用0.asInstanceOf[String]有何不同?

def reduceLeft[B >: A](op: (B, A) => B): B = {
  if (isEmpty)
    throw new UnsupportedOperationException("empty.reduceLeft")

  var first = true
  var acc: B = 0.asInstanceOf[B]

  for (x <- self) {
    if (first) {
      acc = x
      first = false
    }
    else acc = op(acc, x)
  }
  acc
}

额外的问题:为什么acc甚至被初始化为该值?看来for循环的第一次迭代中的代码只会用TraversableOnce对象中的第一个元素覆盖该值。

最佳答案

好吧,这在运行时不会因ClassCastException而失败的原因是:

  • 编译器删除了从未使用过的初始化理由(对此我表示怀疑)
  • B是erasedObject(或AnyRef),因此类型转换实际上是0.asInstanceOf[Object]

  • 您可以通过检查字节码来测试第一种可能性,但这似乎毫无意义。如果不删除它,那么将有不必要的开销,即在每次调用该方法时都将Int装箱(尽管不是创建对象-参见下文)!

    找出编译器产生的结果:1
    Welcome to Scala version 2.9.1.final (Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM, Java 1.6.0_29).
    Type in expressions to have them evaluated.
    Type :help for more information.
    
    scala> trait X[A] {
     | def foreach[U](f: A => U): U
     | def isEmpty = {
     | var b = false
     | foreach(_ => b = true)
     | !b
     | }
     | def reduceLeft[B >: A](op: (B, A) => B): B = {
     | if (isEmpty) sys.error("Bad")
     | var first = true
     | var acc: B = 0.asInstanceOf[B]
     | for (x <- this) {
     | if (first) { acc = x; first = false } else acc = op(acc, x)
     | }
     | acc
     | }
     | }
    defined trait X
    

    所以现在:
    scala> :javap -v X
    Compiled from "<console>"
    public interface X extends scala.ScalaObject
      SourceFile: "<console>"
      Scala: length = 0x
    
      Signature: length = 0x2
       00 0D
      InnerClass:
       public abstract #19= #16 of #18; //X=class X of class
       public final #21; //class X$$anonfun$isEmpty$1
       public final #23; //class X$$anonfun$reduceLeft$1
      minor version: 0
      major version: 49
      Constant pool:
    const #1 = Asciz    SourceFile;
    const #2 = Asciz    <console>;
    const #3 = Asciz    foreach;
    const #4 = Asciz    (Lscala/Function1;)Ljava/lang/Object;;
    const #5 = Asciz    <U:Ljava/lang/Object;>(Lscala/Function1<TA;TU;>;)TU;;
    const #6 = Asciz    Signature;
    const #7 = Asciz    isEmpty;
    const #8 = Asciz    ()Z;
    const #9 = Asciz    reduceLeft;
    const #10 = Asciz   (Lscala/Function2;)Ljava/lang/Object;;
    const #11 = Asciz   <B:Ljava/lang/Object;>(Lscala/Function2<TB;TA;TB;>;)TB;;
    const #12 = Asciz   Scala;
    const #13 = Asciz   <A:Ljava/lang/Object;>Ljava/lang/Object;Lscala/ScalaObject;;
    const #14 = Asciz   InnerClasses;
    const #15 = Asciz   X;
    const #16 = class   #15;    //  X
    const #17 = Asciz   ;
    const #18 = class   #17;    //
    const #19 = Asciz   X;
    const #20 = Asciz   X$$anonfun$isEmpty$1;
    const #21 = class   #20;    //  X$$anonfun$isEmpty$1
    const #22 = Asciz   X$$anonfun$reduceLeft$1;
    const #23 = class   #22;    //  X$$anonfun$reduceLeft$1
    const #24 = Asciz   java/lang/Object;
    const #25 = class   #24;    //  java/lang/Object
    const #26 = Asciz   scala/ScalaObject;
    const #27 = class   #26;    //  scala/ScalaObject
    
    {
    public abstract java.lang.Object foreach(scala.Function1);
      Signature: length = 0x2
       00 05
    
    public abstract boolean isEmpty();
    
    public abstract java.lang.Object reduceLeft(scala.Function2);
      Signature: length = 0x2
       00 0B
    
    }
    

    做到这一点,你会!

    找出编译器产生的结果:2

    另一种可能性是将其放在源文件和compile it, printing out the intermediate code phase中:
    ./scalac -Xprint:icode X.scala
    

    然后你得到...
    def reduceLeft($this: X, op$1: Function2): java.lang.Object = {
      if ($this.isEmpty())
        scala.sys.`package`.error("Bad")
      else
        ();
      var first$1: scala.runtime.BooleanRef = new scala.runtime.BooleanRef(true);
      var acc$1: scala.runtime.ObjectRef = new scala.runtime.ObjectRef(scala.Int.box(0));
      $this.foreach({
        (new anonymous class X$$anonfun$reduceLeft$1($this, op$1, first$1, acc$1): Function1)
      });
      acc.elem
    };
    

    看起来好像里面有不必要的拳击!一点是,这不会涉及对象的创建,而只是查找,因为-127到127的框值被缓存。

    您可以通过将上述打印命令中的编译器阶段更改为“擦除”来检查已擦除的行。嘿,presto:
    var acc: java.lang.Object = scala.Int.box(0).$asInstanceOf[java.lang.Object]();
    

    10-07 16:41